facebook image Living in Middletown, IN - Suburb of New Castle | NextBurb
+Area Type

Area type of a place is calculated based on population density, home ownership, and proximity to various amenties


Best for Family


For Young Professionals


Near College

About Middletown

Middletown is a suburb in the New Castle Metro Area and in the Henry County. It has a population of 2,201 and a population density of 1,899, which is 95% above the national average. It has a median age of 41, which is 1 year below the New Castle Metro median age and 2 years above the national average.

Middletown has a median home value of $137,200, which is 27% above the Metro average.The average rent of $999 is 28% above the metro average rent and 52% below the national average rent. The average household income in Middletown is $56,090 , which is 9% above the Metro average household income and 25% below the national average of household income.

The average school rating in Middletown is 7. Middletown also has a crime index 48 that is below the national average, making it one of the best places to raise a family in New Castle.

$137,200Median Home Value
$100,400 New Castle Metro Area
$999Median Rent
$721 New Castle Metro Area
5 /10 - 8 /10
School Rating
Crime Index
National Crime Index

Middletown Zip Code

Free Neighborhood Recommendations
Try it now

Looking to buy a home? We provide free neighborhood recommendations, backed by our data. Book a free consultation today !


Middletown's population is made up of 41% married, 30% single, 19% divorced and 10% widowed. Baby Boomers make up the largest percentage of the population at 40%, while Millennials have the second largest segment at 28%. Homeowners make up 61% of the population in Middletown.

48,158 New Castle Metro Area
1,899Population Density
  • 49% Male
  • 51% Female
41 Median Age
42 New Castle Metro Area
See Detailed Demographics Data for Middletown, IN

The Per Capita income in Middletown is $27,076. The Median Household Income is $56,090 and the Middletown Unemployment Rate is 5%.

$27,076Income Per Capita
$25,417 New Castle Metro Area
$56,090Median Household Income
$51,104 New Castle Metro Area
11% Poverty Rate
14% New Castle Metro Area
5% Unemployment Rate
4% New Castle Metro Area
See Detailed Employment Data for Middletown, IN
Amenities in Middletown
See Detailed Amenities Data for Middletown, IN
Area Type
$137,200Median Home Value
$100,400 New Castle Metro Area
$999Median Rent
$721 New Castle Metro Area
2Average Household Size
2 New Castle Metro Area

Occupancy Type

Home Owners
See Detailed Real Estate Data for Middletown, IN
5 /10 - 8 /10
School Rating
Ratings By GreatSchools

Top Schools in Middletown

Shenandoah School Corporation School District
5256 North Raider Road, Middletown, IN, 47356
                                            <div class=
PK, K-5
See Detailed Schools Data for Middletown, IN
30 mins Average Travel Time To Work
Commute To
Indianapolis International Airport
1 hr 16 mins
Lawrence Township, IN
52 mins
College Heights Country Club
25 mins
University Park Care Ctr
45 mins
See Detailed Commute Data for Middletown, IN

Middletown crime index is 51 which is lower than the national average. Click here to see the Safest Places to Live in Middletown.

Crime Index
National Crime Index

Crime Index represents the risk of crime occurring in a area and is measured against national index of 100. If the Crime Index of an area is above 100 the crime in that area is relatively higher when compared to US. If the Crime Index of an area is below 100 the crime in that area is lower when compared to US.

See Detailed Crime Data for Middletown, IN
Compare Lifestyle
Compare demographics, real estate, crime and other stats

Your next place to live is waiting for you