facebook image Living in Middletown, IN - Suburb of New Castle | NextBurb
+Area Type

Area type of a place is calculated based on population density, home ownership, and proximity to various amenties


Best for Family


For Young Professionals


Near College

About Middletown

Middletown is a suburb in the New Castle Metro Area and in the Henry County. It has a population of 2,472 and a population density of 2,234, which is 96% above the national average. It has a median age of 35, which is 7 years below the New Castle Metro median age and 3 years below the national average.

Middletown has a median home value of $132,200, which is 24% above the Metro average.The average rent of $999 is 28% above the metro average rent and 6% below the national average rent. The average household income in Middletown is $51,531 , which is 1% above the Metro average household income and 21% below the national average of household income.

The average school rating in Middletown is 7. Middletown also has a crime index 48 that is below the national average, making it one of the best places to raise a family in New Castle.

$129,600Median Home Value
$100,400 New Castle Metro Area
$999Median Rent
$721 New Castle Metro Area
5 /10 - 8 /10
School Rating
Crime Index
National Crime Index

Middletown Zip Code

Free Neighborhood Recommendations
Learn More

Looking to buy a home? We provide free neighborhood recommendations, backed by our data. Booked a free consultation today !

Compare Lifestyle
Compare demographics, real estate, crime and other stats

Your next place to live is waiting for you